Conflicts of Interest Policy

Document Number	000934
Date Approved	18 March 2011
Date Last Amended	18 May 2011

     

 

1.      Introduction

One of the aims of the University’s Code of Conduct is to maintain public trust and confidence in the integrity and professionalism of our graduates, the teaching and learning, research and research training, and community service activities of the University, and the facilities and services that make up the University experience. Acting ethically and with integrity includes a requirement that all persons engaged with or undertaking University business identify, and appropriately manage, conflicts of interest. 

The objective of this Policy is to help employees and others engaged in University business to identify, disclose and manage actual, reasonably perceived or potential conflicts of interest between their interests and their University duty or responsibilities. 

This Policy draws on the guidelines contained in the Independent Commission Against Corruption, Managing Conflicts of Interest in the Public Sector Toolkit. 

2.      Policy Scope

This Policy applies to all University staff, conjoints, students, volunteers, and members of advisory and governing bodies, in all campuses and locations of the University and at all times while engaged in University business or otherwise representing the University.

3.      Policy Intent

The intent of this Policy is to support those involved in University activities in the exercise of their duties, studies and endeavours with integrity.  The objectives are to identify, disclose and manage conflicts of interest in a transparent manner in order to minimise risk, including reputational risk, to the University; minimise risk to individuals; protect the interests of students enrolled in academic programs within the University; and avoid legal issues.  

Conflicts of interest can arise in many situations.  It is not unusual or wrong to have a conflict of interest.  Actual, potential or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest may arise in decision making or in actions, and need to be managed. The purpose of this Policy is to assist in the avoidance of conflicts of interest where possible, and to provide measures which may be used for the appropriate management of issues or situations where conflicts of interest arise.

4.      Relevant Definitions

In the context of this document: 

Conflict (or actual conflict) of interest   arises when an official’s private-capacity interests could adversely affect the proper performance of their official function or duty (OECD, 2004, Guidelines on managing conflict of interest)   A conflict of interest can arise from avoiding personal losses as well as gaining personal advantage – whether financial or otherwise.   

governing bodies means Council and its Committees, the Executive, and other governance committees identified by the Vice-Chancellor. 

perceived (or apparent) conflict of interest  exists where it could be reasonably perceived by a disinterested third party that a person’s private interests could improperly influence the performance of their duties – whether or not this is in fact the case.

potential conflict of interest arises where a person has private interests that could conflict with their official duties in the future.

private affiliations include the personal, professional or business interests of others such as family members and friends, or rivals and enemies.

reportable gift or benefit means

a. any item, travel, hospitality, entertainment or other token of appreciation with a value of more than $100; or

b. a series of any items listed in (a) from a single source within a calendar year (January 1 to December 31), where the value of the gifts collectively is more than $100.

Senior Management Group means Pro Vice-Chancellors, Chief Financial Officer, Heads of School, Directors and Associate Directors.

statement of interests means the written declaration of relevant personal interests, and possibly those interests of other persons closely related to an individual.

5.      Policy provisions / principles

5.1       Identifying conflicts of interest

A conflict of interest exists where there is a divergence between the individual interests of a person and their professional responsibilities such that an independent observer might reasonably conclude that the professional actions of that person are unduly influenced by their own interests (Australian Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research [ACRCR], Section 7).  Conflicts of interest may be actual, perceived, or potential. (ICAC, 42).  They may arise through decision-making or actions.  In all cases, the following tests can be applied to determine if there is a conflict of interest:

• public duty versus private interest;
• potential for benefits now or in the future;
• perception of how a decision or action may be viewed by others; the risk to individual and to the University;  
• proportionality – would it appear fair and reasonable to an independent person;
• presence of mind – what would be the consequences if the issue is ignored; what would be the perception if questioned publicly;
• promises – what commitments have been made; does an individual stand to gain or lose from the action or decision.

Generally the level of risk associated with conflict of interest will increase with an increasing level of leadership or authority and where multiple functions are assigned to one individual. 

Appendix 1 contains a checklist to help identify conflicts of interest. 

Specific areas of high risk to be considered include:

• financial and economic interests, for example shareholding in or directorship of a company dealing with the University by the person concerned or by a partner or immediate member of their family;
• family or private businesses that may have dealings with the University or which may be in competition or conflict with the University;
• family or other relationships with contractors, students, or other staff also working in the University;  
• paid outside employment, being a member of a Committee or Advisory Board, employment by a company dealing with the University or in a role related to an aspect of government policy or operations which affects a matter under consideration by the University;
• future employment prospects or plans;
• affiliations with, or membership of, other organisations and associations (e.g. non profits; political; trade unions; professional organisations)  that may be dealing with the University or in competition or conflict with the University;
• obligations to professional, community, ethnic, family, or religious groups in a personal or professional capacity;  
• enmity or competition with another individual or group.

 

5.2       Prejudicial relationships

Relationships (familial, closely personal, sexual, commercial or involving private affiliations) may lead to a conflict of interest or be prejudicial to professional conduct. Such relationships may be either current or in the recent past, or may have developed between colleagues or a staff member and a student as a consequence of an initial professional association. 

Any relationship between staff members and between staff (whether academic or administrative) and students can be prejudicial where a staff member uses his or her position to the detriment or benefit of a student, other staff member or the University.

Staff must recognise their professional and ethical responsibilities to protect the interests of students, to avoid or manage conflicts of interest, to respect the trust involved in the staff/student relationship and to accept the constraints and obligations inherent in that relationship.

A staff member shall not take part in any matter in relation to any student who is a member of their immediate family, or is currently or has recently been involved in a close personal relationship with that staff member:

The staff member must declare his/her interest and make arrangements to avoid taking part in any of these matters; such arrangements shall be approved by the Head of School or Division; or, if the Head of School or Division is the person involved, then by the Pro Vice-Chancellor of the Faculty or Division and, if the Pro Vice-Chancellor is the person involved, then by the relevant Deputy Vice-Chancellor.

5.3       Responsibilities

5.3.1    General responsibility

It is the responsibility of all those covered by the Scope of this policy to be aware of their obligation to identify, disclose and appropriately manage conflicts of interest which may arise at any time during the course of duty or while on University business.  This includes an assessment of private and personal interests and whether they conflict or have the potential to conflict with official duties, and the disclosure of actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest. 

When confronted by an actual, potential or perceived conflict of interest, those covered by the Scope of this Policy, must formally disclose the conflict of interest and its nature.  This must be in a form appropriate to the situation, either in writing, by email or by advice to a line manager or Chair of a meeting.  A record of declared actual and potential conflicts of interest will also be maintained in a manner appropriate to the situation.  For example, if a disclosure is made during a meeting, this disclosure and the action taken by the Chair to manage the situation should generally be minuted.  It is preferable in such circumstances that the person concerned does not remain in the room, even if silent, while the matter related to the disclosure is debated and decided. (ACRCR, Section 7.1.3)

It is the responsibility of line managers to ensure that staff are aware of this Policy and to facilitate compliance by those they supervise. 

Where a line manager, Chair of a governance body or other relevant person or body becomes aware of an actual, potential or perceived conflict of interest that has not been declared, they should discuss the matter with the individual, encourage full disclosure and take action applicable to the situation.  If appropriate, a formal disclosure and management strategy as identified in Section 5.7 must then be put in place.

While all conflicts of interest must be disclosed, on rare occasions, there may be an ethically acceptable reason for not disclosing the specific nature of the conflict, for example if this would breach another person’s privacy.  In such cases, the individual must still declare that a conflict of interest exists and the line manager or Chair of a Committee must be satisfied that the conflict can be managed without its nature being disclosed.  [ 5.4.6 National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research 2007 ]

5.3.2    Standing declarations

Standing Statement of Interests Declarations are required for all members of University governing bodies.  Members must complete a Declaration upon their appointment, and prior to the first meeting of each calendar year thereafter.  The Declaration to be used is at Appendix 2. 

The Vice-Chancellor and Deputy Vice-Chancellors must make a standing Statement of Interests Declaration upon their appointment, and annually thereafter by 30 January of each year. The Declaration to be used is at Appendix 2. 

Members of the Senior Management Group must make a simplified standing Statement of Interests Declaration upon their appointment, and annually thereafter by 30 January of each year.  The declaration to be used is at Appendix 3.

Making a Statement of Interests Declaration does not remove the obligation on those covered by this Policy to disclose an actual or potential conflict of interest should one arise, or to take appropriate action to resolve or manage the conflict of interest. 

5.3.3    Conflict of interest – disclosure at University governance meetings

All meetings of governing bodies will commence with a declaration by those present that no conflict of interest exists in any matter before the meeting.  Where a conflict of interest is disclosed, the Chair will decide, based on the matter under consideration and the nature of the conflict, the appropriate course of action.  This may include the person being stood down from the discussion or not participating in voting or resolutions.  The interest that is disclosed, the nature of the conflict and the manner in which it is managed will be minuted. 

It is best practice to request a declaration of conflicts of interest at all University meetings.  Such declarations are required at University meetings where there are decisions involving personal or confidential information, and where natural justice and procedural fairness issues are paramount, such as staff or student misconduct matters, allegations of research misconduct, and meetings involving tenders. 

5.3.4    Areas of high risk

Directors, Heads of School, and their equivalents or above, who are responsible for areas and processes where there is a high risk of conflicts of interest arising are required to ensure that specific procedures are put in place to manage the risks posed by potential conflicts of interest.

These areas include:

• research activities, including disclosure to funding bodies and for individuals responsible for carrying out any part of an investigation of an allegation of research misconduct;
• procurement processes, tenders and contracts;
• recruitment, selection,  appointment, re-classification, termination, tenure, promotion, staff development, conditions of service;
• collection and use of personal information;
• exercising financial and other delegations;
• sponsorships to or from the University.  

 

5.4       Gifts and benefits

Staff and members of University governing bodies must not solicit nor accept gifts or benefits either for themselves or for another person which might in any way be seen to directly or indirectly compromise or influence them in their official capacity.

Gifts of money, including gift or store vouchers, are never acceptable.  Gifts of nominal value (less than $100 as a guide) used for promotional purposes by the donor may be accepted.  Individuals must, however, be satisfied that they cannot be compromised by the acceptance. 

Individual gift(s) in excess of a value of $100, as well as multiple gifts from the same source totalling in excess of $100, must:

1. preferably be gift(s) to the Faculty/Division of the University; and
2. be declared in the Gifts and Benefits Register to be maintained in HROnline.

If an individual has any doubt in relation to a particular matter, direction should be sought from the relevant Pro Vice-Chancellor or Head of Division. 

5.5       Register of conflicts of interest, gifts and benefits

The University will maintain a conflict of interest record for all persons who are required to complete a Statement of Interests Declaration. 

Declarations made by Council members who are not University employees, will be held by the University Secretary.  Declarations made by University employees will be held by Human Resource Services. 

The University will also maintain a Gifts and Benefits Register for all staff to report any gifts and benefits individually or cumulatively in excess of $100 in value through the HRonline system. 

Note: The declaration form at Appendix 4 should be used until the HRonline form is operational.

 

5.6       Management of Conflict of Interest

Appropriate management of conflicts of interest may include:

• restricting the involvement and access to information of those concerned in matters in which they have, or are perceived to have, a conflict of interest;
• re-assignment of persons from matters in which they have actual or potential conflicts of interest;
• involvement of third parties who do not have an interest to participate in the matter;
• relinquishment of assets or private interests; 
• resignation from the position which has placed the person in an unmanageable conflict of interest situation.  

The most appropriate strategy will depend on an assessment of the nature of the conflict, the complexity of the situation and the subtleties and severity of the case.

In the area of research ethics review, management measures may include requiring that: the information be disclosed to research participants; a person other than the researcher make the initial approach to participants; the information be disclosed in any report of the research; the research be conducted by another researcher; the research not be conducted.  [ Section 5.4.3 of the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research 2007 ]  

5.7       Concerns

Where a member of staff or a student has concerns or perceives that a conflict of interest exists, the matter should be discussed with the relevant line manager, supervisor or senior staff member. If the matter cannot be raised or resolved in this way, contact should be made with the Complaints Management Office and the matter dealt with in accordance with the provisions of the Complaints Resolution Policy.

Where the conflict of interest concern involves fraud or corruption the individual should report the matter immediately using the provisions of the Internal Reporting Policy.

5.8       Consequences for non-compliance

Non-compliance with the provisions of this Policy, including refusal to take any reasonable action as directed to resolve a conflict of interest, is a serious matter.  Depending on the severity and implications of the breach, action may be taken under misconduct provisions of the relevant agreement, or student disciplinary proceedings, and sanctions may include a warning, counselling, or disciplinary action. 

Breaches of this Policy may also result in referral to, and action being taken by, a statutory authority and/or agency. 

5.9       Review and Oversight

Information contained in the standing Statement of Interests Declarations will be provided to the Nominations and Legislation Committee in camera at the first meeting of each year. 

Information on the Gifts and Benefits Register will be provided to the Audit and Risk Management Committee at the first meeting of each year. 

Information held may be used for University purposes including audit, reporting, compliance monitoring and other purposes required by government, legislation or University workplace agreements, rules, policies or procedures.

5.10     Privacy Management

Information arising from conflict of interest disclosures, Statement of Interests Declarations and declarations of reportable gifts and benefits will be managed in accordance with the University's Privacy Management Plan 000258. 

6.      Further information

Further information may be obtained by contacting:

• the relevant PVC or Head of Division or Unit;
• the University's Legal Unit;
• The office of the NSW Ombudsman.

7.      Appendices

Appendix 1 – Checklist for Assessment of Areas of Potential Conflicts of Interest

Appendix 2 – Statement of Interests Declaration – members of governing bodies, Vice-Chancellor and Deputy Vice-Chancellors

Appendix 3 – Statement of Interests Declaration – Senior Management Group

Appendix 4 - Disclosure of Reportable Gifts or Benefits Form

8.      Essential Supporting Documents  

University of Newcastle Act 1989, Schedule 2A (external site)

University Code of Conduct 000059

Code of Ethical Academic Conduct Policy 000607

Responsible Conduct of Research Policy 000873

Investigation of Allegations of Research Misconduct Guidelines 000872

Complaints Resolution Policy 000745

Privacy Management Plan 000258

National Health and Medical Research Council, the Australian Research Council and Australian Vice-Chancellor’s Committee, 2007, National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research      (external site)

National Health and Medical Research Council, the Australian Research Council and Universities Australia, 2007, Australian Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research [ACRCR]      (external site)

Conflict of Interest Guideline for Research Higher Degree Supervisors 000950 

9.      Related Documents

Fraud and Corruption Prevention Policy 000472

Commercial Activities Guideline 000554

Internal Reporting – Staff Policy 000618

Paid Outside Work Policy 000835

Independent Commission Against Corruption, 2004, Managing Conflicts of Interest in the Public Sector Toolkit.  (external site)

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) 2004, Guidelines on managing conflict of interest  (external site)

Student Misconduct Rule 000935

 

Approval Authority	Council
Date Approved	18 March 2011
Date Last Amended	18 May 2011
Date for Review	18 March 2013
Policy Sponsor	Vice-Chancellor
Policy Owner	University Secretary
Policy Contact	Director, Human Resource Services
Amendment History	16 November 2011 - Added Related Link to Conflict of Interest Guideline for Research Higher Degree Supervisors 000950 approved 18 May 2011. 23 August 2011 - Administrative amendments due to implementation of Student Misconduct Rule which replaced Student Discipline Rules effective 25 July 2011. Minor amendment 26 July 2011 - Clause 5.5 amended to reflect the need for staff to complete a declaration form until the information is included in HRonline. Minor changes to format of Declarations at Appendix 2 and 3 based on feedback received, Governance and Policy, 13 July 2011. Approved by Council - 18 March 2011. It replaces and rescinds: • Avoiding Conflicts of Interest Policy - 000420 • Conflict of Interest Policy - 000562 • Conflicts of Interest in Assessment Policy - 000651 • Prejudicial Relationships Policy - 000255 • Receipt of Gifts by Members of The University Policy - 000281 • Disclosure of Interests / Conflict of Interests (Members of Council and Senior Staff) Procedure - 000563 • Conflict of Interest - Guidelines for University Members Appointed to the Boards of Companies, Including University Controlled Entities - Guideline 000864