The University of Newcastle Australia
Infoskills logo
Go to Main Menu Go to Site Map Find Help
Section of pie chart representing validity  
 
Validity

It can be difficult to judge the validity of information in a discipline in which you are not familiar. Consider the following:

  • Does the train of thought and ideas expressed in the information source make sense, or does it contradict itself?
  • How much information does the author provide about how they obtained their data? Are the research methods and data collection techniques used to support the information valid in the discipline?
  • Have counter arguments and alternative explanations been acknowledged and considered?
  • If there is a bibliography or references listed, are the authors experts in that field?
  • If sources such as statistics are used to support an argument are they collated from reliable sources?
  • Has the information been reviewed by an expert in the field? If the information source is a journal article, has it been through a peer-review process?
  • What are the advantages or disadvantages of relying on a native speaker/scholar’s viewpoint of another culture, as opposed to an “outsider’s” viewpoint?
 
Previous page